Playing to Win vs. Playing Not to Lose: Mental Lessons from the 2025 Ryder Cup

The Ryder Cup always delivers theatre, but beyond the drama there are valuable lessons every golfer can take into their own game. The 2025 edition at Bethpage was a textbook case of how our performance changes depending on whether we are striving to achieve a goal or trying to avoid a bad outcome.

Over the first two days, Team Europe played fearless golf. They pushed hard, built momentum, and surged ahead by taking their chances. On the final day, though, with a healthy lead to defend, their mindset subtly shifted. Instead of attacking to win, many players slipped, either subconsciously or through fatigue, into a mode of protecting what they had. The result? The U.S. came storming back, and Europe suddenly looked less comfortable, more tentative, and more vulnerable.

It’s a lesson as old as competitive sport: when we switch from a “play to win” mindset to a “don’t mess it up” mindset, our performance usually suffers.

Why striving beats avoiding

From a performance psychology perspective, the difference comes down to approach vs. avoidance goals.

• Approach goals are about striving toward something: hitting a fairway, sinking a putt, winning a hole.

• Avoidance goals are about steering clear of mistakes: don’t go in the bunker, don’t miss left, don’t throw away the lead.

• 
  

The problem is that avoidance goals focus your mind on what you don’t want. That increases anxiety, diminishes your access to your skills, moves your attention somewhere useless, and makes you more reactive. Approach goals, on the other hand, orient your mind towards possibility, execution, and growth. They enable you to commit and play freely.

At Bethpage, Europe’s Saturday golf was full of approach focus — “let’s extend the lead.” On Sunday, the avoidance trap crept in — “let’s not blow the lead.” And the shift was obvious.

How this applies to your game

Even if you’re not facing roaring crowds at Bethpage, you’ve almost certainly felt this shift on the course. Think about these situations:

• You’re one shot ahead in your club match with two holes to play — do you swing freely, or do you suddenly guide the club, trying not to hit a bad one?

• You’ve had a great front nine and are on for your personal best — do you keep committing to your targets, or do you start playing away from trouble, hoping just to “hang on”?

• You’ve got a 4-footer for par after a great chip — do you roll it in with confidence, or do you “try not to miss”?

  
  

The difference between those mindsets is often the difference between success and frustration.

Practical ways to stay in “striving mode”

The good news is that you can train yourself to stay in approach focus, even under pressure. Here are a few simple strategies:

1. Set positive shot goals

Instead of “don’t miss left,” reframe your target: “Commit to the right edge of the green.” Every shot should have a clear, positive intent.

2. Use “towards” language

The words you use shape your mindset. Replace don’t and avoid with action cues like commit, swing through, start on line.

3. Anchor your pre-shot routine in commitment

Before pulling the trigger, ask yourself one question: “What does a good shot look like here?” If you can’t answer clearly and positively, reset.

4. Play mini-games within your round

Like Europe did early in the Ryder Cup, give yourself small approach challenges: “Score on the next 3 holes,” or “Hit 3 solid tee shots in a row.” These keep you moving toward something, rather than holding on to what you have.

5. Review success by intent, not just outcome

After a round, don’t only ask “What did I score?” Ask: “How many shots did I fully commit to?” This keeps your growth tied to striving behaviours rather than fear of mistakes.

Closing thoughts

The 2025 Ryder Cup reminded us that even the best players in the world can slip into defensive, avoidance-based golf when the stakes are high. Europe nearly paid for it on Sunday at Bethpage.

For your game, the lesson is simple but powerful: performance improves when you strive to achieve something, not when you’re just trying to avoid a mistake. Whether you’re chasing your handicap goals, playing a medal round, or in match play with friends, commit to playing with intent, not with fear.

Because golf — like the Ryder Cup — is won by those who play to win, not by those who play not to lose.